So after spending a good bit of time at Pycon over the past week and a half I finally decided to push through and make the switch. I have been working with https://mycroft.ai/ for the past month or so and I’m loving it. In fact so much as you can see from this post I have removed my Alexa’s. Let me explain why below.
Alexa Is Insecure
Alexa by nature is very insecure and I don’t like the idea of not really knowing at any given time what is going on. Thankfully to mycroft being open sourced I have complete access to the logs and know exactly what is being recorded, when, and what is being sent to their Speech To Text (STT) engine and transcribed. I also don’t like the fact to manage certain internal devices there has to be a open line out on the Internet, just seems a little insecure and the model of mycroft works better for myself and I would think for any security like minded individuals. Below is a powerpoint showing how the Mycroft architecture works:
Alexa Has Minimal Wake Words
So another issue I had with Alexa was the wake words. They are very minimal right now and don’t really leave any options open for what you want to use. I currently use the famous J.A.R.V.I.S for mine but can be really anything. If curious look at this doc about how to change them on mycroft here
Mycroft Is Flexible
The main reason I like mycroft is it so open and flexible. I am able to create skills for new things that don’t exist yet very easily. This has led me to go ahead and switch over to mycroft sooner rather than later and start coding up any missing skills as I need them. I currently have created twitter skills and skills to manage my home automation program, https://home-assistant.io/, you can find my repo at https://github.com/btotharye
Early Adopter Benefits
By starting out early on this framework and project I am able to learn quite a bit and be a big part of helping out in the community which I love. It leads to me finding new issues to fix and learn how to become a better coder by having active issues and skills to create and program for. It also allows me to assist in making the product more consumer based in the future to allow it to be used by anyone even if you don’t know how to code necessarily or might be new to computers.
Great Community Support
I urge you to check out mycroft via https://mycroft.ai/ and take a look at their mark 1 as well as picroft options to run on a pi. Check out https://mycroft.ai/get-mycroft/ for a list of available ways to start using mycroft, and check my blog for more upcoming posts on setting up mycroft and building your first skill.